Tuesday March 9 2010 1254 pm
In Transracial Adoptions, Race DOES Matter
Posted by Tracy Hahn-Burkett under Adoption , Our Cultures, Races & Religions , Parenting on a Daily Basis , The World We Parent InLeave a Comment
International adoptions out of Haiti are much in the news these days following January’s devastating earthquake. In one article last week, ABC News introduced us to Duke and Lisa Scoppa, who just adopted two young boys from Haiti. At first glance, this seems like it could only be a happy story (and so far as I know, it is). But there’s a difficult side to adoptions like the Scoppa’s, one that sometimes goes unacknowledged: Haitian children adopted by white American parents are likely to struggle with their racial identities at some point in their lives, as are any other transracial adoptees. As much as some people wish race didn’t matter, it does, and it’s not something that can be glossed over in any transracial adoption.
As is pointed out in the article, some people believe that black children should never be adopted by white parents. I cannot agree with this position. To my mind, a loving home and a loving, committed family is the paramount goal for any child. But I have more than once met people, including adoptive parents, who have stated their belief that race is irrelevant and that their different-race children should not have harbor any racial concerns growing up because his or her parents believe that everyone is equal. That sentiment, however well-intended, ignores reality, and we adoptive parents do our kids a huge disservice if we ignore that reality and fail to incorporate race-consciousness into our parenting.
At the risk of being accused of stepping even deeper into this minefield (hey, someone’s got to do it), it’s worth noting that the context of black-and-white transracial adoptions in the United States is somewhat unique, obviously existing within the context of the history of U.S. black-white race relations in general. But that doesn’t mean that racial identity is only important for black children, or for black children adopted into white families. Racial identity is meaningful across the board, and all parents who adopt transracially—of any race—need to integrate racial identity issues into the raising of their children.
The ABC News article is worth reading. If you’re an adoptive parent of a child of another race who doesn’t think you need to worry about race, I’m going to go so far as to implore you to read it and think about the world from your child’s perspective, not your own.
Even if you’re not an adoptive parent, it’s worth taking a couple of minutes to read the article and think about an issue that probably never occupies your mind. Why? It’s interesting. It’s a change from using your coffee-break time to chat with your friends on Facebook. And you might learn something. What have you got to lose?












